These women still see themselves as nice Jewish girls, and that's part of the appeal too. Angel says that while she's open to double penetration, there are certain things a good tribe member just won't do. She's rejected offers to perform in holiday-themed adult fare like this year's Dr. Suzy's Porn & Purim DVD Bacchanal, which mixes group sex with hamantaschen. "I've desecrated Christian traditions before," says Angel. "In one video, I put a cross-shaped dildo inside me, but I'd never do that with a menorah—that's just creepy."

[Read More: Circumcised men are submitting to foreskin-stretching devices to reverse the unkindest cut of all]