JENI'S
Ohio's inventive Jeni Britton Bauer buys ingredients from local farms to make seasonal frozen yogurts such as tangy lemon-and-blueberry and a Riesling-poached-pear sorbet.
$68 for 6 pints, jenisicecream.com


CAPOGIRO
This Philly institution's dense gelati rival Italy's finest, especially its Sicilian pistachio and the yellow watermelon spiked with grappa.
$60 for 6 pints, capogirogelato.com


VOSGES
The famed candy-maker takes a crack at the cold stuff, infusing ice cream with unexpected fixings—e.g., pandan leaf and ancho chiles.
$45 for 4 pints, vosgeschocolate.com

Read More:
Overnight Gourmet: The Most Delicious Mail-Order Food
Ice Breakers: Two Amazing Popsicle Recipes
Breakout Books—and Treats—by Mail